Illustration by  
January 18, 2022

What is actually the difference between copyright and moral rights?

Words by  

If you’re a freelancer, it’s vital that you pay attention to copyright for two reasons.

Firstly, because you may need to protect your own copyrighted work. And secondly, because otherwise you may end up infringing someone else’s copyright in the process of your work, and getting slapped with a lawsuit.

The basics of copyright are pretty straightforward (if you need a refresher, check out this gov.uk post). But if you’re not in the mood to click that link, essentially copyright gives you rights in any work that’s new and original, whether that be a book, a film, a painting or even the design of a building.

But what sometimes confuses people is talk of ‘moral rights’. For example, at the front of most books you’ll see a sentence along the lines of ‘[Name] asserts his/her moral right to be identified as the author of this work in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.’ 

So what are moral rights, exactly? In this article, we’ll answer that question, and explain why creative freelancers should care.

Moral rights are part of copyright law

The first thing to understand is that moral rights are not separate from copyright law, but a part of it.

Copyright gives you two kinds of rights over your work. Firstly, you’re granted economic rights. These give you the right to profit from use of your work, and prevent other people from making money from it without permission.

So, for example, if you wrote a blog post and someone published it in a book or magazine without your permission, you’d have the right to sue them for compensation.

Secondly, copyright grants you moral rights, which protect your non-financial interests in your work. So rather than protecting your bank balance, they’re primarily about protecting your reputation. 

What do moral rights apply to?

Moral rights protect, among other things, literary works, artistic works, musical works, dramatic works and films.

However, they do not apply to sound recordings. This means that while a musician can assert moral rights over the music and lyrics of a song, they can’t assert moral rights over any particular recording of that song. 

There are four specific moral rights offered by UK copyright law, made explicit in The Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 (other territories may vary). We’ll look at each of these in turn. 

  1. The right to attribution

You have the moral right to be recognised as the creator of a work. An obvious example is that if you write a book, you’d expect to see your name on the published edition.

There’s something important to remember, here, though. To be given the right to attribution, you have to first assert it.

So to take the book example, when you’re drawing up a contract with your publisher, you’d want a clause included that asserts your right to be identified as the author. Alternatively if, say, you were exhibiting a painting at an exhibition, you’d want some kind of sign on or near it, identifying yourself as its creator.

The name you wish to be identified by can be your own or a pseudonym; it’s up to you. And note that you only have to assert this right once, you don’t have to keep doing it (phew!).

Be aware, though, that there are exceptions. For example, attribution doesn’t have to be given if your work is featured in a newspaper or magazine, a reference book such as an encyclopedia, or if it appears accidentally in a film or broadcast. 

That said, if you work in the media or entertainment industries and are on the other side of this relationship, it’s always good practice to attribute creative work where you can; for example, attaching a caption in a newspaper article, or adding a credit at the end of a movie. (Plus, well, it’s just polite anyway.)

Note that the right to be identified only applies to works created after 1 August 1989, and does not apply to the authors of computer programs, computer-generated works, typefaces, or works protected by crown copyright.

  1. The right to object to false attribution

The second moral right you have as a copyright owner is a logical offshoot of the first. You have the right not to be named as the author of a work you did not create.

For example, if someone other than Banksy spray-painted a piece of street art and falsely signed it ‘Banksy’, they’d be infringing the famed graffiti artist’s moral rights.

It’s important to add, though, that for action to be taken, the falsely attributed work must have been publicly exhibited, broadcasted or distributed in some way. You don’t have to prove that the false attribution caused you harm or damaged your reputation, just that it took place.

False attribution is something you need to think about carefully when it comes to parodies. In 1998, for example, the politician Alan Clark won £250,000 in damages against the Evening Standard newspaper in London, after they published a spoof column titled ‘Alan Clark’s Secret Diaries’. The court held that the headline was a clear case of false attribution, and that the appearance of the real author’s name at the bottom was insufficient to counteract this.

  1. The right to object to derogatory treatment of a work

The way the above sentences is worded, it sounds like you can stop people criticising your work! But while that would be many creative freelancers’ dream, that’s not what it means.

In reality, it means you have the right to protect your work from being altered or distorted, in a way that ruins your reputation. An example might be if you wrote a play, went to see it performed, and found that the director had added a sub-plot that invoked racist stereotypes.

That said, this is a tough right to enforce, as you must prove your reputation has been damaged.

For example, in 2003 musician Andrew Alcee sued Warner UK, after they licensed one of his songs, and then overlaid it with rap lyrics by The Heartless Crew referring to violence and drug culture.

The judge, however, ruled against Alcee, on the basis that the rap lyrics were hard to decipher, and that he could present no compelling evidence that his reputation had been damaged.

Another case in 1996 was brought by the Private Eye cartoonist Bill Tidy, who’d entered into a contract with the National History Museum, to create a series of cartoons about dinosaurs to be displayed at an exhibition.

The cartoons he produced were 420 x 297mm, but the museum went on to reproduce them in a book at just 67 x 42mm. They also changed the background colour from white to pink and yellow. None of this was with Tidy’s consent.

However, the judge ruled that it was not obvious that this had damaged the cartoonist’s reputation. And the absence of witnesses to back up Tidy’s claim meant he had to rule in the museum’s favour.

Be aware that the same exceptions that apply to your attribution rights also apply here. This right also explicitly excludes translations of literary works, or arrangements or transcriptions of musical works involving nothing more than a change in key or register.

  1. The right to privacy of certain photographs and films 

The final moral right is quite specific. If you have commissioned a photograph or film for private purposes, then you have the right to prevent it from being made public. This right could be enforced, for example, to prevent a wedding photographer putting images of your happy day on their website or Instagram.

When moral rights don’t apply 

Moral rights sound great, don’t they? However in practice, a lot of the time freelancers don’t actually have moral rights in their work. Why? Because while moral rights can’t be sold, they can be ‘waived’. And many clients will insist on this when drawing up your contract.

Whether you resist this and insist on retaining your moral rights will vary from profession to profession. For instance, the National Union of Journalists recommends that you immediately write back and refuse any requests to sign away your rights, and the organisation offers help with drafting a response to such ‘copyright grabs’. In contrast, it’s quite normal for musicians to waive their moral rights when selling music to be used as soundtracks in movies.

Your approach will also depend on your level of experience and standing within your profession. For example, a young and keen photographer may be less concerned about their moral rights than kickstarting their career; while a veteran who’s in high demand will be in a much better position to push back. Either way, before you sign any freelance contract, make sure you check for any mention of waiving your moral rights, so you can make an informed decision.

Finally, be aware that moral rights don’t last forever. Like copyright in general, they persist for the life of the author plus 70 years, or just 20 years in the case of false attribution.

Learn how you can turn your freelance gig into a money making business. It’s FREE!

Free 15 min freelancing consultation call
Advice and practical steps to level up your business
Learn how to consistently find work
Get tips for finding your niche

Recommended Reading

How to make your business more cost effective in 2022

Review your subscriptions Evaluate your phone and internet providers Don’t expense for the sake of it Think about where you’re working from Sell off excess equipment The UK has been experiencing a cost of living...

A Field Guide to Bad Clients (and how to deal with them)

What we suggest 1. Get a contract that secures weekly hours2. State your terms at the bottom of every invoice and outline your late fees3. Don’t reply to emails outside of work hours. Schedule your reply to be...

How should journalists build their social media brand?

For better or worse, I can almost guarantee that every young journalist will have come across the phrase “JournoTwitter” at least half a dozen times as they work to break the glass ceiling in their...

Writers beware: Avoid the content mill

Like many other freelance writers, I stumbled into the industry somewhat by accident. Before COVID-19, I had been living a cushy life abroad, basking in the satisfaction of not having to update my LinkedIn. But...

Detaching self-worth from work

This second instalment of the self-worth and work topic will focus on the people who are actively working on detaching their self-worth from their work. I have struggled with this task ever since I dipped...

How to network as a freelancer in 2022

A common misconception about freelancing is that it’s only something you can do after you’ve established yourself within your industry. This is because freelancing is something many people do later on in their careers, having...

Defining your time; or how to avoid being on call 24/7

Defining your time; or how to avoid being on call 24/7

Don’t be afraid to set your own time. That’s probably why you became a freelancer, after all.

Is email killing your freelance productivity?

Is email killing your freelance productivity?

Emails are great. But they can also really really slow you down. Here are some ways to make sure your most useful tool doesn’t stop you from actually doing work

Do not let non-competes kill your business

Do not let non-competes kill your business

Non-competes can kill your business. Do not let them. Here’s how

Freelancers, this is how to take control of your money

Freelancers, this is how to take control of your money

The 30% rule is going to make your life a lot easier. Make sure you follow it if you’re a freelancer looking to manage their money more consistenly

Retainer clients are the dream. How do you find good ones?

Retainer clients are the dream. How do you find good ones?

Consistency? Haven’t heard of her. But if you want to a place where you can take risks with your freelance career, retainer clients are the way to stability.

The magic word every freelancer needs to know

The magic word every freelancer needs to know

It’s often the first word we learn, but it’s the last one we’re willing to say. How can saying “No” more often be the magic word every freelancer needs to know?

How do you create a portfolio straight out of university?

How do you create a portfolio straight out of university?

Coming out of uni with only limited work experience feels like it means you can only apply for entry level roles. But uni students can build fantastic work-sealing portfolios with some small tips and tricks

Freelance networking groups: How to join in and build your business without spamming

Freelance networking groups: How to join in and build your business without spamming

Do you want to talk about your business on an FB group but don’t want to be THAT person? There are ways to discuss work without seeming self-serving. Click up to find out.

How to onboard new clients as a freelancer

How to onboard new clients as a freelancer

If you’re signing new clients, that’s fantastic. But the first and second steps of the relationship are vital to keeping things positive. Having a consistent onboarding system can get your started in the right place.

How to tackle portfolio procrastination

How to tackle portfolio procrastination

Making good portfolios is crucial for your freelance business, but it can be tempting to procrastinate. Check out UnderPinned’s Virtual Office for portfolio templates to fill and send to clients!

The difference between Portfolios and Proposals

The difference between Portfolios and Proposals

So you’re hunting for freelance work? Well, what do you say when a potential client asks for a proposal rather than a portfolio? Have a read to see.

Freelancing with ADHD

Freelancing with ADHD

Freelancing is for everyone. But a job that requires skills you struggle with can make freelancing with ADHD difficult. Hear from an expert and a freelancer with ADHD about how she makes it work.

How to go freelance straight after uni

How to go freelance straight after uni

How do you go freelance straight after uni? You honestly ask yourself if you’re ready, and then you just lean into it 100%. And you read this article to find out more.

Signs of a weak freelance portfolio that clients spot at once

Signs of a weak freelance portfolio that clients spot at once

What signs in your portfolio are you hoping that clients see? And what are you hoping will be good filler? Make sure you’re only putting things in there that you can defend

Ten actionable tips for freelancers to relieve their WFH fatigue

Ten actionable tips for freelancers to relieve their WFH fatigue

WFH has been tough. But, a year into the change for many people, there are still learnings to be had. Zoom past fatigue with our tips

Ten things you should never say to a freelancer

Ten things you should never say to a freelancer

Vent your client frustrations through us! A must read for anyone that hires/knows/ever talks to a freelancer, here’s ten things never to say to a freelancer

Kill The Boss In Your Head: Freelancing and Creativity

Kill The Boss In Your Head: Freelancing and Creativity

Through the tension and anxiety at the heart of all paid freelance work, what are the conditions that best support the free-flowing of creativity?

One year ago I turned to freelancing to save my mental health: Here’s what happened

One year ago I turned to freelancing to save my mental health: Here’s what happened

Fiona Thomas writes on her switch to freelancing pushed by her mental health, and how someone in a similar scenario can benefit from the change

A guide to being a creative freelancer without social media

A guide to being a creative freelancer without social media

We could all do with a break from social media. But how do you continue to run your creative freelance business without your Instagram? Here’s a guide.

An extension of your arm: Must-have tools for freelance content creators

An extension of your arm: Must-have tools for freelance content creators

Want an aresenal of tools in your pocket that can make your freelance life expontentially easier? Look no further

The role of the creative brief and why it’s so vital to get right

The role of the creative brief and why it’s so vital to get right

Here’s how to be clear with clients about what you need from their brief, and what they should expect from you too in the beginnings of the conversation

Building it alone; Freelancing when you’re single

Building it alone; Freelancing when you’re single

Being freelance is tough enough. But doing it all alone can make it a lot more complicated. Here’s how to take some steps to make it easier on you.

A guide to juggling multiple freelance clients

A guide to juggling multiple freelance clients

You want freelance success? You probably will need more than one client. Finding them is one thing, but keeping them organised? Oh boy. Luckily we have a guide just for you.

Freelance journalists, here’s how to make ALCS work for you

Freelance journalists, here’s how to make ALCS work for you

If you’re a freelance journalist, you might have a chance at passive income from the ALCS that you didn’t know about.

How writers and journalists can make money with Substack

How writers and journalists can make money with Substack

Want to escape from the editorial loop? Substack is on everyone’s lips right now. But how can you use it as a writer?